Oyster Bay

About Oyster Bay Homes & Town

Get to Know Oyster Bay, NY

with Oyster Bay real estate agent Ted Kritikos

Oyster Bay is a coastal hamlet on the North Shore of Long Island known for its ties to President Theodore Roosevelt and his summer White House, Sagamore Hill. Oyster Bay is home to pretty beaches, numerous fishing piers, and a quaint village with unique shops and popular restaurants.

More About Oyster Bay, NY

History
Oyster Bay is a town located in Nassau County, New York. It was originally settled by Native Americans and later became an important port for the whaling industry in the 18th and 19th centuries. The town played a significant role in the American Revolution and was the site of several important battles. Today, Oyster Bay is known for its historic landmarks and charming downtown area.

Geography
Oyster Bay covers an area of about 2 square miles and is situated on the North Shore of Long Island. The town is located on the Long Island Sound and is known for its beautiful waterfront views. Oyster Bay is primarily a residential community with a mix of historic homes and newer properties. The area is also home to several parks and beaches, including Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park and Centre Island Beach.

Oyster Bay Real Estate
Oyster Bay is a desirable place to live for those looking to live near the water on Long Island. The town is known for its historic homes, many of which date back to the 1800s and early 1900s. There are also many newer properties in the area, including condos and townhouses. If you’re looking for real estate in Oyster Bay you can search Oyster Bay homes for sale, below.

Conclusion
Oyster Bay is a picturesque town with a rich history and beautiful natural surroundings. Its historic landmarks, charming downtown area, and waterfront views make it a popular destination for tourists and a desirable place to live for locals. While the cost of living in Oyster Bay may be higher than other areas in Nassau County, it is still more affordable than many surrounding communities on the North Shore of Long Island. If you’re looking for a small-town feel with access to parks, beaches, and historic landmarks, Oyster Bay’s real estate may be the perfect place for you.

Oyster Bay Neighborhood Guide

oyster-bay-village

Neighborhood Points of Interest

SAGAMORE HILL NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE
Former “Summer White House” of President Theodore Roosevelt. Tours are available require advance booking.

PLANTING FIELDS ARBORETUM
400+-acre estate featuring formal gardens, greenhouses, and woodland paths.

RAYNHAM HALL MUSEUM
Museum showcasing Colonial and Victorian eras right in downtown Oyster Bay.

THEODORE ROOSEVELT SANCTUARY & AUDUBON CENTER
The first Audubon songbird sanctuary in the nation, this 14-acre preserve features woodland trails, bird habitats, and conservation programs.

Welcome to

Oyster Bay

Oyster Bay Neighborhood Guide

Oyster Bay is a historic North Shore hamlet rich in charm and heritage.

As one of Long Island’s most storied waterfront communities, its bustling downtown offers a mix of locally owned shops, restaurants, and cultural landmarks that serve residents and visitors alike. The hamlet is closely connected to surrounding areas such as Centre Island, Cove Neck, and East Norwich.

Beyond its Main Street, Oyster Bay boasts a vibrant harbor, pristine parks, and preserved estates that highlight the natural beauty and maritime legacy of the region.

Oyster Bay Demographics

Population (2026 Estimate)
6,945*

Average Household Income (2024)
$135,863**

Average Sales Price (04/2026 – 06/2026)
$860,000***

Source: World Population Review, 2026 estimate.

*Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024.

**Source: OneKey MLS, closed single-family homes and condos, Q2 2026, as reported by Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty.

Eat & Drink Favorites

BONANZA’S
Italian-ice legend for over a century, this little shack scoops dozens of flavors plus light bites.

TWO SPRING
Sophisticated, modern American eatery plating tasting menus and multi-course dishes for intimate gatherings.

COOPER BLUFF
Oyster Bay’s only waterfront bar, situated right on Oyster Bay Harbor. Beautiful views, great cocktails and live music make this a local favorite.

SOUTHDOWN COFFEE
Casual cafe and coffee shop known for locally roasted beans and baked goods served all day.

Scroll to Top