Oyster Bay Neighborhood Guide
Neighborhood Points of Interest
SAGAMORE HILL NATIONAL HISTORIC SITE
Former “Summer White House” of President Theodore Roosevelt. Tours are available require advance booking.
PLANTING FIELDS ARBORETUM
400+-acre estate featuring formal gardens, greenhouses, and woodland paths.
RAYNHAM HALL MUSEUM
Museum showcasing Colonial and Victorian eras right in downtown Oyster Bay.
THEODORE ROOSEVELT SANCTUARY & AUDUBON CENTER
The first Audubon songbird sanctuary in the nation, this 14-acre preserve features woodland trails, bird habitats, and conservation programs.
Welcome to
Oyster Bay
Oyster Bay Neighborhood Guide
Oyster Bay is a historic North Shore hamlet rich in charm and heritage.
As one of Long Island’s most storied waterfront communities, its bustling downtown offers a mix of locally owned shops, restaurants, and cultural landmarks that serve residents and visitors alike. The hamlet is closely connected to surrounding areas such as Centre Island, Cove Neck, and East Norwich.
Beyond its Main Street, Oyster Bay boasts a vibrant harbor, pristine parks, and preserved estates that highlight the natural beauty and maritime legacy of the region.
Locust Valley Demographics
Population
6,708*
Average Household Income
$403,604*
Average Sales Price (8/2023 – 8/2024)
$1,174,372**
*World Population Review
**OneKey MLS for closed residential real estate during period.
Eat & Drink Favorites
BONANZA’S
Italian-ice legend for over a century, this little shack scoops dozens of flavors plus light bites.
TWO SPRING
Sophisticated, modern American eatery plating tasting menus and multi-course dishes for intimate gatherings.
COOPER BLUFF
Oyster Bay’s only waterfront bar, situated right on Oyster Bay Harbor. Beautiful views, great cocktails and live music make this a local favorite.
SOUTHDOWN COFFEE
Casual cafe and coffee shop known for locally roasted beans and baked goods served all day.